The Hidden Costs of Gentrification
Gentrification not only changes a neighborhood’s appearance but also how residents’ concerns are addressed, often leading to more policing.
Read Time: 4 minutes
Published:
The coffee shops with $8 lattes arrive first, then the fancy gym. Rents climb, and long-time residents start to feel like strangers in their own neighborhoods. This is the familiar story of gentrification. But one chapter often goes untold: what happens when new residents start calling the police?
In a recent scoping review, my colleagues and I examined 26 studies from cities around the world to understand how neighborhood change shapes policing and what that means for health.
As neighborhoods gentrify, policing tends to intensify, but not necessarily in response to more crime. Instead, it often becomes more about managing who belongs in public spaces. Our review identified three main pathways driving these changes: new residents calling emergency and non-emergency lines; investors and developers pressuring city officials to increase security to protect financial interests; and police departments themselves adopting more order-maintenance strategies in changing neighborhoods.
The resident-driven pathway works like this: newcomers move into historically Black, Latino, or low-income neighborhoods. They see behaviors that have always been part of the community (think: teenagers hanging out on stoops or playing music in parks) and interpret them as disorder. They call 311. They call 911. One study found that for every 1% increase in White residents moving into a previously disinvested neighborhood, proactive policing (as measured by non-emergency calls for service) rose by 5%.
One consistent finding across the literature describes how gentrification transforms the purview of policing. It shifts from preventing crime to regulating behavior.
These calls have potentially serious consequences for health. Research shows they’re linked to higher stop-and-frisk rates for Black residents and more citations against people experiencing homelessness. Long-term residents describe feeling surveilled, anxious, and treated as suspicious for simply existing in their neighborhood.
For the most marginalized—people who use drugs, sex workers, people experiencing unsheltered homelessness—the pressure becomes acute. They rush through drug use, increasing the risk of overdose and skin and soft tissue infections. They isolate themselves. They move to unfamiliar, hidden locations where the risks of violence increase. Once-robust social networks can fracture under the strain.
The anticipation of police contact alone can trigger hypervigilance—a constant state of threat assessment that wears down the body over time. For Black and Latino communities already bearing the weight of structural racism, this added burden contributes to “weathering,” the premature aging and health decline that comes from cumulative stress.
One consistent finding across the literature describes how gentrification transforms the purview of policing. It shifts from preventing crime to regulating behavior: deciding who looks like they belong and who doesn’t. A drumming circle that’s happened for decades suddenly becomes a noise complaint. Youth playing basketball become “loiterers.” The neighborhood’s culture becomes evidence of disorder.
The negative effects of gentrification do not have to be a foregone conclusion.
The populations most affected are those who were already vulnerable: Black and Latino residents, people experiencing homelessness, people who use drugs, and sex workers. These groups face the sharpest scrutiny and experience the most significant health and social consequences, but the dynamics are complex.
Concerns about drug use or sex work in a neighborhood aren’t unique to newcomers. What gentrification changes is how those concerns get addressed—often through punitive enforcement that pushes vulnerable people into more dangerous situations rather than connecting them with services. Behavioral crises, substance use, and even noise complaints become matters for the criminal legal system rather than public health or social services, narrowing the range of responses available and increasing the likelihood of harm.
The negative effects of gentrification do not have to be a foregone conclusion. Criminal legal reforms shifting toward non-police alternative responses (such as behavioral health professionals for non-emergency calls) could help ensure that this overlooked chapter tells a different story.
Housing and business development policy changes are also an essential part of reform. In Houston, Texas, for example, a community land trust was established to protect long-term Black residents from being displaced from rapidly gentrifying neighborhoods and create a path to homeownership. Increasing the stock of low- and middle-income housing and encouraging new business development in currently disinvested neighborhoods would also better support communities’ economic futures and social stability.